Mine accidents: some features of the planning and formation of the methodology of their investigation

Planning the investigation of criminal cases related to mining accidents plays a crucial role in effectively organising investigative work. It contributes to a prompt, objective and comprehensive clarification of the circumstances of the incident. Also, it allows for the determination of the optimal set of organisational and priority investigative measures. This approach includes immediate formulation of investigation tasks; putting forward and verifying versions of the causes of accidents of a criminal nature; developing methods and tactics for verifying them; widespread use of scientific and technical means and rational tactical decisions. Particular attention is paid to creating an algorithm of necessary investigative actions when drawing up a plan; the specifics of conducting a mining and technical examination; questioning representatives of the mine management and engineering and technical personnel. Based on the analysis, the authors propose specific measures to improve the methodology and planning of accident investigations at mining enterprises. 

1. V Kazahstane rabochie kalechatsja v tri raza chashhe, chem v Evrope. URL: https://kz.kursiv.media/2022-01-29/v-kazakhstane-rabochie-kalechatsya-na-proizvodstve-v-tri-raza-chasche-chem/ (In Russian).

2. Smailov A. Bolee dvuh tysjach rabotnikov ezhegodno poluchajut proizvodstvennye travmy v Kazahstane. URL: https://sozmedia.kz/26160/ (In Russian).

3. Lugovskaja N. Smertnost’ na kazahstanskih predprijatijah rastjot. URL: https://alau.kz/smertnost-nakazahstanskih-predprijatijah-rastet/ (In Russian).

4. Otsutstvie normativno-pravovoj bazy tormozit rassledovanie ugolovnyh del po faktam gibeli ljudej v ugol’nyh shahtah. URL: https://kaztag.kz/ru/news/otsutstvie-normativno-pravovoy-bazy-tormozitrassledovanie-ugolovnykh-del-po-faktam-gibeli-lyudey-v-ugolnykh-shakhtakh-politsiya (In Russian).

5. Sergeev O.D. (2019) Tipovaja kriminalisticheskaja harakteristika prestupnyh narushenij pravil bezopasnosti pri vedenii gornyh rabot (st. 216 UK RF) i ee znachenie dlja rassledovanija dannogo vida prestuplenij // Konceptual’nye osnovy sovremennoj kriminalistiki: teorija i praktika. Materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii. – Minsk: BGU. P. 127–129. (In Russian).

6. Prikaz ministra po chrezvychajnym situacijam Respubliki Kazahstan ot 17 avgusta 2021 goda № 404. Pravila provedenija rassledovanija i uchjota avarij i incidentov na opasnyh proizvodstvennyh ob#ektah, tehnicheskogo rassledovanija sluchaev utrat vzryvchatyh veshhestv i izdelij na ih osnove. URL: https://www.gov.kz/uploads/2021/8/31/3d6518681acfd699b6d8690625506bd6_original.70422.pdf. (In Russian).

7. Golik A.S., Zubareva V.A., Apal’kov A.S., Zhuravlev R.P. (2013) Sredstva kollektivnoj zashhity shahtjorov i gornospasatelej v avarijnyh uslovijah shaht. Bezopasnost’ truda v promyshlennosti. No.1. P. 16–19. (In Russian).

8. Averin V.O. (2020) K voprosu o sudebnoj gornoj jekspertize // Vestnik Nauchnogo centra po bezopasnosti rabot v ugol’noj promyshlennosti. No. 3. P. 66–69. (In Russian).

9. Kurlenja M.V. (2017) Vzryvy metana na vysokoproizvoditel’nyh uchastkah ugol’nyh shaht i prichiny ih vozniknovenija // Fiziko-tehnicheskie problemy razrabotki poleznyh iskopaemyh. No. 5. P. 71–78. (In Russian).

10. Belkin R.S. (2001) Kriminalistika: problemy segodnjashnego dnja. Zlobodnevnye voprosy rossijskoj kriminalistiki. M.: Izdatel’stvo NORMA. 240 p. (In Russian).

11. Rjazanova N.V. (2008) Taktika doprosa ochevidcev jekstremal’nyh sobytij. Avtoreferat dis. kand. jurid. nauk: 12.00.09. Sankt-Peterburg. 45 p. (In Russian).

12. Jeanne Darc Manik, A. Rachmad Budiono, Prija Djatmika, Nyoman Nurjaya (2017) Investigation of Criminal Acts in Mining of Minerals and Coal by Investigators Civil Servant // Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization. Vol. 61. P. 91–97. (In English).

13. Sergeev O., Safargalieva O., Volgin Yu. (2021) Inspection of the Scene at the Initial Stage of the Investigation of Criminal Violations of Safety Rules during Mining // E3S Web of Conferences., no. 278, p. 02007. URL: https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127802007SDEMR-2021. (In English).