Evaluation of the admissibility and reliability of an expert opinion in criminal proceedings
https://doi.org/10.46914/2959-4197-2024-1-2-48-53
Abstract
This article is devoted to the problem of assessing the admissibility and reliability of an expert’s opinion in the context of criminal proceedings. The expert’s opinion, as an important evidence in criminal cases, is an integral part of the judicial process. However, its admissibility and reliability play a crucial role in the formation of court decisions. The purpose of this study is to conduct a comprehensive assessment of the admissibility and reliability of the expert’s opinion in criminal proceedings. The article discusses the main aspects of assessing the admissibility of expert opinions, including the issues of expert qualification, his independence, methodology of work, as well as compliance with professional standards. The importance of strict procedure and supervision of experts to ensure the objectivity of conclusions is noted.
About the Authors
S. B. Bakyt
Kazakh National University named after al-Farabi
Kazakhstan
Kazakhstan
m.l.s., specialist
Almaty
G. T. Alayeva
Kazakh National University named after al-Farabi
Kazakhstan
Kazakhstan
c.l.s., professor
Almaty
References
1. Teorija dokazatel'stv v sovetskom ugolovnom processe / Pod red. Zhogina N.V., Karpec I.I. M., 1967. P. 301. (In Russian).
2. Gorskij G.F., Kokorev L.D., Jel'kind P.S. (1978) Problemy dokazatel'stv v sovetskom ugolovnom processe. Voronezh. P. 168. (In Russian).
3. Belkin R.S. Sobiranie, issledovanie i ocenka dokazatel'stv. URL: http://www.lawlibrary.ru/izdanie5767.html (data obrashhenija: 10.10.2024). (In Russian).
4. Grishin A.V. (2011) Kak pravil'no ocenivat' zakljuchenija jeksperta po ugolovnomu dela // Ugolovnyj process. No. 11. P. 60–67. (In Russian).
5. Nikulenko O.O. (2015) Osparivanie zakljuchenija jeksperta po ugolovnomu delu // Ugolovnyj process. No. 5. P. 42–48. (In Russian).
6. Giverts P., Griber A., Kokin A.V. (2022) On the Criteria for Evaluating an Expert’s Opinion and Forensic Methods by Participants in the Legal Proceedings // Theory and Practice of Forensic Science. No. 17(1). P. 27–37. (In English).
Review
For citations:
Bakyt S.B., Alayeva G.T. Evaluation of the admissibility and reliability of an expert opinion in criminal proceedings. Eurasian Scientific Journal of Law. 2024;(2 (7)):48-53. (In Kazakh) https://doi.org/10.46914/2959-4197-2024-1-2-48-53
Views:
56
Email this article 