Proportionality of punishment as principle of criminal law and problems of its practical application in Republic of Kazakhstan

The article examines principle of proportionality of punishment as key element of criminal law and mechanism for limiting state repression in Republic of Kazakhstan. Theoretical approaches to understanding proportionality are considered, including retributive, functional and operational aspects, as well as their influence on formation of modern criminal policy. Special attention is paid to analysis of normative foundations of implementation of principle of proportionality through general principles of sentencing, judicial practice and explanations of highest judicial bodies. Main problems of law enforcement are identified, including template nature of judicial reasoning, inconsistency in sentencing, difficulties in application of norms on more lenient punishment, as well as risks of disproportionality in cases of concurrence of offenses. Influence of stage of execution of punishment, including parole and probation, on actual severity of criminal impact is separately analyzed. Necessity of improving mechanisms for ensuring proportionality through standardization of judicial practice, development of alternatives to imprisonment and strengthening institutional guarantees of fairness of punishment is substantiated. Results of study can be used in improvement of criminal legislation and judicial practice. Practical significance of work lies in formulation of recommendations aimed at increasing effectiveness and predictability of sentencing.

1. Normativnoe postanovlenie Verhovnogo suda Respubliki Kazahstan ot 25 ijunja 2015 goda № 4 «O nekotoryh voprosah naznachenija ugolovnogo nakazanija». URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/P150000004S (data obrashhenija: 12.01.2025) (In Russian)

2. Kodeks Respubliki Kazahstan ot 3 ijulja 2014 goda № 226-V ZRK «Ugolovnyj kodeks Respubliki Kazahstan». URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/K1400000226. (data obrashhenija: 12.01.2025) (In Russian)

3. Ugolovnyj kodeks Respubliki Kazahstan: Kodeks Respubliki Kazahstan ot 03.07.2014 № 226-V ZRK (s izmenenijami i dopolnenijami). URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/K1400000226/k226_.htm (data obrashhenija: 12.01.2025) (In Russian)

4. O sudebnom prigovore: Normativnoe postanovlenie Verhovnogo cuda Respubliki Kazahstan ot 20 aprelja 2018 goda № 4 (s izmenenijami i dopolnenijami). URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/P180000004S (data obrashhenija: 23.01.2025) (In Russian)

5. Manikis M. (2022) The Principle of Proportionality in Sentencing: A Dynamic Evolution and Multiplication of Conceptions // Osgoode Hall Law Journal. Vol. 59. No. 3. P. 587–628. DOI: 10.60082/28175069.3812 (In English)

6. Pina-Sánchez J., Linacre R. (2016) Refining the measurement of consistency in sentencing: A methodological review // International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice. Vol. 44. P. 68–87. DOI: 10.1016/j.ijlcj.2015.06.001 (In English)

7. Lovegrove A. (2000) Proportionality, Sentencing and the Multiple Offender: Towards a Numerical Framework // Punishment & Society. Vol. 2. No. 4. P. 453–469. DOI: 10.1177/146247400222281 (In English)

8. Śliwiński E. (2023) Principle of proportionality as a threat to criminal-law-related fundamental rights // New Journal of European Criminal Law. Vol. 14. No. 3. P. 327–344. DOI: 10.1177/20322844231158 (In English)

9. Mukasheva D., Tulkinbayev N., Prilutskaya M., Yessimova D., Stöver H. (2024) Behind bars: Understanding prisoner perception of penitentiary rehabilitation in Kazakhstan // International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice. Vol. 77. Article 100669. DOI: 10.1016/j.ijlcj.2024.100669 (In English)

10. Mitskaya E., Sarykulov K., Utarov K. (2025) On Manoeuvring Kazakhstan’s Criminal Law in Defining Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman, and Degrading Treatment and Punishment // Access to Justice in Eastern Europe. Vol. 8. No. 1. P. 62–84. DOI: 10.33327/AJEE-18-8.1-a000102 (In English)

11. Bizhan N., Bekimbetov T., Persheyev A., Rahmetova G., Dairabayeva G. (2018) Features of Humanization of the Criminal Policy of Kazakhstan: Study of the Possibilities to Increase the Effectiveness of Punishments in the Context of International Experience // Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics. Vol. 9. No. 5 (35). P. 1604–1610. DOI: 10.14505/jarle.v9.5(35).11 (In English)

12. Konstitucija Respubliki Kazahstan. Prinjata na respublikanskom referendume 30 avg. 1995 g. URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/K950001000_ (data obrashhenija: 25.01.2025) (In Russian)

13. Ob utverzhdenii Koncepcii pravovoj politiki Respubliki Kazahstan do 2030 goda. Ukaz Prezidenta Respubliki Kazahstan ot 15 oktjabrja 2021 goda № 674 (s izmenenijami i dopolnenijami). URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/U2100000674. (data obrashhenija: 25.01.2025) (In Russian)

14. O probacii. Zakon Respubliki Kazahstan ot 30 dekabrja 2016 goda № 38-VІ ZRK (s izmenenijami i dopolnenijami). URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/Z1600000038 (data obrashhenija: 24.01.2025) (In Russian)

15. Ob institutah uslovno-dosrochnogo osvobozhdenija i zameny nakazanija bolee mjagkim vidom : special’nyj doklad Upolnomochennogo po pravam cheloveka v Respublike Kazahstan. Astana, 2025. URL: https://www.gov.kz/uploads/2025/7/18/00b3b819c00c8e8699b4134e30796ce5_original.1963559.pdf (data obrashhenija: 12.01.2025) (In Russian)

16. Rakhimberdin K.Kh. (2025) Probation in the Republic of Kazakhstan: Current Issues and Development Trends // Scientific and Legal Journal “Bulletin of the Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan”. Vol. 80. No. 3. DOI: 10.52026/2788-5291_2025_80_3_167 (In English)